The cell therapy space has been hit hard over the past year triggered by a perfect storm of events from the macro-economic environment:
- Biotechnology has come under pressure, where investors fear not only dilution but extinction; and
- Companies in the Small-Cap Biotech space often operate with a years worth of cash, and this has made investors nervious.
We have been down this road in the past, can anybody say Y2K?
Dendreon's (NASDAQ: DNDN) rise became the rallying cry for investors so its subsequent plunge became the proof for the bears that cell therapy just doesn't work. Both examples are in our opinion false. Provenge, like so many biotech products before it, is the first in a new therapeutic category. We lived through the monoclonal antibodies in the 90's, and then the HIV market in Y2K. Most recently the success of the nucleosides (Pharmasset) is now destined to be acquired by Gilead (GILD). We hope our followers saw the run up in Inhibitex (INHX) that resulted.
What's the connection? A pattern has emerged, and Provenge is not just a cell therapy but the first of a cell based approach to immunology/cancer. The follow-on products will be better. Take a look at the work that PrimaBioMed (ASX: PRR) is doing or even better, Coronado (OTCBB: CNDO) (which we have been following for some time).
What we want to begin discussing today is cell therapy on the regenerative medicine side of the equation. Oncology has always had tough hurdles but on the regenerative side the unmet medical need is often just as great, in fact, greater in some places.
No one yet has been able to explain Mesoblast (MSB-Australia) to us but Cephalon and now Teva are in partnership and the stock has a market cap approaching $2 billion. This is an allogenic (other peoples cells) model, which pharma likes. It is the so called pills in a bottle model. Peer companies include Pluristem (PSTI) and Athersys (ATHX), at much lower valuations ($100 million or lower). On the autlogous side no one seems to be paying any attention to NeoStem (AMEX: NBS). This company acquired Progenitor Cell Therapy the contract manufacturing company that worked on Provenge and today is working with many of the cell therapy companies we are following.
Can an autlogous model work? Baxter thinks so, and has been highlighting their autlogous cells for cardiac ischemia. Interesting because the Baxter product is very similar to the NeoStem product - both are CD34+ cells with some differences. NeoStem is begining their Phase 2 trial for a cell therapy that promises to stabilze failing hearts after a heart attack.
We recently attended the Stem Cell Therapy on the Mesa conference, and we were "blown away" with the number of products in clinical trials. We saw companies from all over the world - some had revenues with approved products, and others had great data and proof of concept with thereapies that can work for everything from cardiovascular disease to healing damaged muscles and tendons.
Going Forward: We will be actively following the "Cell Therapy Space" now. That means we will be watching the developments on two fronts:
- Oncology/Immunology side, and
- Regenerative Medicine side.
We will be commenting on the trials, the news developments in the space, the competitive landscape, talking with managment, and posting our articles on where we believe the ground breaking science, product profiles, and catalysts lie that can trigger the next paradigm shift in the space.
Remember, Lipitor is going to leave a big hole in Pfizer's pipleine as it goes generic. Pharma and Biotech have to act. Early signs abound that cell therapies are no longer a case of if, but when, and the answer to that is tied to clinical trials, which represent a highly defined process.